The Coaches' Room
GeneralMultiple / GeneralTrials & Recruitment

Would you tell an U9 that a scout is watching?

Asked by AfterWorkCoach82
0 views 4 replies
heard before game someone from pro club was there looking at few players. nobody had told kids yet. i would rather they just play, but some say player deserve know. what would you do at this age?

VERIFIED COACH ANSWER

VERIFIED COACH RESPONSE

UEFA C Coach

U7–U11 early pathways, trials and playing up

Why don't we show coach names?
At U9 I would usually let them play without telling them. Knowing a scout is watching can change a child’s behaviour very quickly. They may force actions, stop passing or become frightened of making a mistake. The scout is there to observe the player in their normal environment, so normal behaviour is useful for everybody. If there is a specific reason the club or family needs to tell the child, keep it very low-key and avoid turning the game into a test. I would certainly not announce it to the whole team. Children will have plenty of time later to learn about selection and observation. At nine, protecting a natural match experience is usually more valuable than making them feel they have to perform for somebody on the side.

COMMUNITY DISCUSSION

Join the football discussion. 4 replies

S

Sully

Community Member

If there is a formal club process that requires the family to know, fine. That still does not mean the child needs a pre-match announcement.
P

PhilP

Community Member

Do not tell them. If the scout wants to see the player, surely they want to see the player rather than their impression of an audition.
B

BeachWalkUK

Community Member

Only caveat for me is if the child already knows and everyone is awkwardly pretending otherwise. Then keep it low-key rather than make it a secret.
H

Hannah

Community Member

Parent view: I would want to know as the adult, but I would not tell my nine-year-old before the game.