The Coaches' Room
GeneralMultiple / GeneralCoach Development

The session looked worse after we coached it

Asked by OldWhiteboard
0 views 8 replies
We worked on playing through midfield and by the end the players looked less fluent than at the start because they were thinking about every movement. I left wondering whether we had overcomplicated it or whether that messy stage is sometimes part of learning. How do people judge that after a session?

VERIFIED COACH ANSWER

Verified Coach avatar
VERIFIED COACH RESPONSE

UEFA B Coach

9v9 tactical • player development

Why don't we show coach names?
That can be part of learning. A session does not have to look smoother at the end to have been useful. If you have introduced a new way of seeing the game, players may temporarily become slower because they are consciously thinking about something that was previously automatic. The question is whether the mess is connected to the learning problem. If the players are confused about three different instructions, the session may be overcomplicated. If they are repeatedly noticing the right picture but getting the execution wrong, I would be more patient. Afterwards, ask yourself what the players were trying to solve, how often they saw that problem and whether your interventions made the decision clearer. At U13, I would rather a session contain useful struggle than look tidy because the players already know every answer. Messy is not automatically good. But tidy is not automatically learning either.

COMMUNITY DISCUSSION

Join the football discussion. 8 replies

T

tea_then_work

Community Member

We ask ourselves: did the session create useful problems or just confusion? Those are not the same thing.
S

Smithy77

Community Member

I judge it at the next session more than the end of the same one. If the players recognise the picture quicker next time, the messy first night probably did something.
A

Aaron_6

Community Member

This is why I stopped needing the final game to look polished. Sometimes the evidence turns up a week later.
P

PlayerDevPete

Community Member

When a coach gives me a new idea I can look slower for a while because I am checking it consciously. That does not mean I have not understood.
S

SarahM

Community Member

I have had sessions that looked worse because the players were genuinely thinking. The question I ask afterwards is whether the mistakes were about the problem we were trying to solve.
W

WoollyHatUK

Community Member

Yes. If the errors are all connected to trying the new behaviour, I am much less worried than if the group has simply lost the purpose.
S

SaturdayGaffer82

Community Member

Mess can be learning, but it can also be us giving too much information. If every player is looking at me before moving, I assume I have overcoached it.
A

AndyM

Community Member

From the side you can usually tell the difference. Thinking looks hesitant; confusion looks like nobody knows what the game is anymore.