The Coaches' Room
GeneralMultiple / GeneralGeneral Coaching

Suspected concussion but the player says they are fine

Asked by BristolRebecca
1787 views 11 replies
We had a collision where the player wanted to carry on and the parent initially thought they looked okay. Nobody wants to diagnose from the touchline, but coaches still have to make an immediate participation decision. How should grassroots teams make sure everybody understands the concussion process before this situation happens?

VERIFIED COACH ANSWER

Verified Coach avatar
VERIFIED COACH RESPONSE

UEFA C Coach

Grassroots session design • 5v5 & 7v7 formats

Why don't we show coach names?
I would treat this as a concussion concern, not a debate about whether the player feels okay. Current FA guidance still uses the principle: if in doubt, sit them out. The coach’s immediate job is to remove the player from football and follow the current concussion process. It is not to diagnose the injury or be persuaded by the child wanting to continue. This is why the club should make the process clear to coaches and parents before the incident happens. In the moment, everybody is emotional and the player may be desperate to get back on. I would make sure coaches know where the current England Football concussion guidance is, who records the incident and what information is given to the parent/carer. Return to football should then follow the current medical/concussion guidance rather than a touchline judgement. When there is doubt about a head injury, the football can wait.

COMMUNITY DISCUSSION

Join the football discussion. 11 replies

M

MattT

Community Member

I also record every suspected concussion even when the player seems fine later. The next adult needs to know what happened.
C

CharlieP

Club Volunteer / Official

We put head-injury reporting next to our first-aid process, not inside the match tactics handbook. It made the seriousness clearer.
W

WL76

Community Member

Parents need the same preseason briefing. Otherwise the coach can become the bad guy for applying a rule nobody knew about.
A

AaronInOxford

Community Member

The return-to-play part also needs consistency. Different coaches should not give different messages once the player misses the next session.
K

Kev

Community Member

Agreed. We direct families to the current guidance and do not create a team-specific shortcut because a cup game is coming.
M

Maz84

Community Member

From an official's point of view, I would rather a team takes too much caution than asks me whether the player looked concussed. That is not my diagnosis to make.
O

OpenAgeOllie82

Community Member

Our coach removed my daughter after a head knock even though she was furious. I was grateful later because in the moment she would have said anything to keep playing.
A

Aisha_14

Community Member

That is why the decision cannot rest with the player. Competitiveness is not a reliable concussion assessment.
D

DefendingDan

Community Member

We added the concussion guidance link to the team handbook. It made the process feel like a club standard rather than one coach being over-cautious.
K

kelly_here

Community Member

We discussed concussion with parents at preseason so Saturday is not the first time they hear 'they are not going back on'. That reduced arguments.
O

Olivia_99

Community Member

The hardest part is when the child looks normal and insists they are fine. I want the coach to make the safety decision, not put it back on a nine-year-old.